GMK vs. MTNU Keycaps: Which Profile Feels Better for Typing?

Quick answer

If you prefer a familiar, low-profile feel with a consistent row profile, GMK-style Cherry profile is a safe bet. If you want a more sculpted, spherical feel with a vintage vibe, MTNU offers a distinct typing experience. Your choice comes down to whether you value familiarity or a more pronounced finger placement.

When you're choosing keycaps, the profile is just as important as the colorway. GMK keycaps are known for their Cherry profile, a classic cylindrical shape that's been a staple for decades. MTNU, on the other hand, brings a spherical top that's more reminiscent of vintage boards. Both have loyal fans, but they feel quite different under your fingers.

In this comparison, we'll break down the key differences between GMK and MTNU profiles, focusing on typing feel, sound, and fit. We'll also look at specific sets from NovelKeys to help you decide which profile suits your typing style.

Profile Shape and Typing Feel

GMK keycaps use a Cherry profile, which features a cylindrical dish on the top. This shape guides your fingers toward the center of each key, making it easier to hit the right spot without looking. The rows are sculpted, meaning each row has a different height and angle, which can reduce finger travel and make long typing sessions more comfortable.

MTNU keycaps have a spherical top, similar to SA or OEM profiles but with a lower overall height. The dish is deeper and more curved, which some typists find gives a more precise, tactile feel. The spherical shape can also affect the sound, often producing a slightly deeper, thockier tone compared to the higher-pitched clack of Cherry profile.

• Try both profiles if you can; typing feel is subjective and depends on your hand size and technique.

Sound and Acoustics

The profile of a keycap influences the sound it produces when it bottoms out. Cherry profile keycaps are generally thinner and have a shorter overall height, which can result in a crisper, higher-pitched clack. MTNU keycaps are thicker and have a more substantial feel, which often translates to a deeper, more muted thock.

If you're building a keyboard for a quiet office or for streaming, the deeper sound of MTNU might be more pleasant. If you prefer a classic mechanical keyboard sound, Cherry profile might be more familiar. Remember that the switch, plate, and case also play a big role in the final sound.

Compatibility and Layout Support

Both GMK and MTNU sets from NovelKeys come in standard kits that support common layouts like 60%, 65%, TKL, and full-size. However, the exact kit contents can vary, so it's important to check the product page for your specific board. Some sets offer separate novelty kits or expansion modules for extra coverage.

MTNU sets often include a variety of kits, such as base and novelty kits, letting you customize your board. GMK sets typically come in a single base kit that covers most standard layouts. Make sure your board uses standard key sizes and spacing, as some proprietary layouts may not be fully supported.

Aesthetics and Colorways

The profile also affects the look of your keyboard. Cherry profile keycaps have a uniform, low-profile appearance that many find clean and modern. MTNU keycaps, with their spherical tops and sculpted rows, have a more retro, almost vintage look that stands out on a desk.

Both profiles are available in a wide range of colorways, from muted and professional to bright and playful. The choice often comes down to personal style, but if you want a board that looks like it came from the 80s, MTNU is a strong contender.

The trade-offs at a glance

• Familiarity vs. novelty: Cherry profile is the industry standard, so it feels instantly familiar to most typists. MTNU's spherical shape is a departure that some find more comfortable and others find unusual. If you're new to custom keycaps, Cherry is a safe start; if you're adventurous, try MTNU.
• Sound: clack vs. thock: Cherry profile tends to produce a crisper, higher-pitched sound, while MTNU's thicker, more sculpted caps often yield a deeper, thockier tone. Consider your environment and preference for acoustic feedback.
• Aesthetics: modern vs. retro: Cherry profile has a clean, low-profile look that fits most modern setups. MTNU's spherical top and sculpted rows give a vintage, almost nostalgic appearance. Match the profile to the vibe you want your desk to have.

Keycap sets to consider

• Cherry Copper: Cherry Copper is a keycap set designed by fatboycarney, offered by NovelKeys, LLC. This set is crafted in a Cherry profile and made from PBT plastic, providing a durable and classic typing experience for mechanical keyboard enthusiasts. If you're leaning toward the GMK Cherry profile, this PBT set gives you that familiar typing feel with a durable material that resists shine over time.
• MTNU 800 OS2.0: Hold on to your 8-bits, and travel back to 1979 with the MTNU 800 keycap set. Inspired by the Atari 800, this set shines with the centered legends and the spherical profile of MTNU. The soft brown base color, the vintage cream legends, and the orange gradient accents all combine to bring this heritage look to your modern mechanical keyboard. This set is a perfect example of the MTNU profile's vintage aesthetic and spherical feel, ideal if you want a typing experience that stands out from the crowd.

Which profile fits you?

Best for

• Typists who want a familiar, low-profile feel with a consistent row profile.
• Builders who prefer a crisp, classic mechanical keyboard sound.

Not for

• Those who want a more sculpted, spherical feel that reduces finger travel.
• Users who prefer a deeper, thockier sound profile.

Both GMK and MTNU profiles have their strengths, and the right choice depends on your personal typing style and aesthetic preferences. If you value familiarity and a classic feel, Cherry profile sets like Cherry Copper are a solid pick. If you're drawn to a vintage look and a more pronounced finger placement, MTNU sets like MTNU 800 OS2.0 offer a unique experience. Whichever you choose, NovelKeys has options to help you find the perfect fit for your board.